Maybe we need a movement to decolonise computing -
A history of the algorithm would uncover the original work in
designing tables for ordnance and a lot of early work (e.g. in UCL at
dept of statistics) on eugenics (and its somewhat less offensive
cousin actuaries) - later on, the adoption of The Algorithm for
targetted advertising and market research derives mostly from its
shady past in cod psychology (psychometrics) and market research -
I suspect that there's a lot of early computing was done by code
slaves who tugged their forelocks at their better (much better) paid
bosses amongst the Mad Men, until later, that culture was "written
through" onto the very bones of the authors of the recommender codes,
long after the advertising execs had retired to their beachfront
properties...
So not only to thee algorithms inherit the sample biases of the data,
they embed the cognitive biases of the culture...
Of all the past endeavours in computing, one area I think might have
some kind of honourable ancestry is in operations research - i
remember state monopoly utilities had armies of very smart
statisticians using cunning statistics to optimise the (centrally
planned) delivery of essential services (gas, water, electricity,
telecom, roads, town planning etc etc) - this all vanished during
western humanity's religious fervour and obsession with The Market,
and the bizarre idea that the invisible hand would implement an
emergent, distributed optimisation that would out-perform the central
computation.
Now we see that the bias in that belief was really about what
optimisation goal was really sought (rich get richer, rather than
lean, mean delivery of basical quality of life for all), but even more
ironically, the digital version of that market is a now not a market,
but an oligopoly of profiteering, centralised planning - plus ca
change...
And we can see in the UK right now, all those privatised (non digital)
utilities are, under cover of bed time stories for little children
(i.e. lies) like Brexit, Covid, Ukraine, etc), making higher profits
than ever (check out transport, energy, food etc) -
Truly, we are in a world turned upside down, and it is well past time
to turn it back downside up once more...
1 comment:
I really enjoy reading through the posts and the perspective they open up...
Post a Comment